As MLB The Show 25 continues to evolve with mid-season updates, the infielders dominating the diamond this September have become clear. From power hitters to defensive stalwarts, infielders can make or break a team’s performance in Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, and Road to the Show modes. With stats, real-life performance, and in-game mechanics all considered, this tier list identifies the top-performing infielders and explains why they stand out in MLB The Show 25 Stubs   this month.

Tier S: Elite Infielders You Cannot Ignore

Tier S represents the cream of the crop: infielders who excel in every facet of the game. These players combine elite hitting, speed, defensive range, and clutch ability, making them game-changers on any squad.

1. José Ramírez – 3B, Guardians
José Ramírez continues to dominate third base, combining power and plate discipline like few others. In MLB The Show 25, Ramírez boasts excellent contact ratings both for right- and left-handed pitching, alongside a high power rating that makes him lethal in the middle of the lineup. His speed allows for extra bases, steals, and aggressive baserunning. Defensively, Ramírez’s arm strength and reaction times make him a reliable asset on the hot corner.

2. Freddie Freeman – 1B, Dodgers
Freddie Freeman remains a top-tier first baseman due to his blend of hitting consistency and situational awareness. With an A+ contact rating and the ability to drive the ball to all fields, Freeman thrives in any lineup configuration. He’s particularly valuable in modes like Diamond Dynasty, where clutch hitting and adaptability under pressure are essential. While not the fastest on the bases, his defensive range and fielding ratings make him a dependable cornerstone for the infield.

3. Trea Turner – 2B/SS, Phillies
Turner’s versatility and speed make him a nightmare for opposing pitchers. In MLB The Show 25, he maintains elite contact and steal ratings, enabling high on-base production. As a middle infielder, Turner also excels in defensive plays, with quick reactions and exceptional arm accuracy. His ability to cover both second base and shortstop at a high level makes him incredibly flexible for team building, especially in modes that allow roster customization.

Tier A: Highly Effective Infielders with Minor Weaknesses

Tier A infielders are elite, but they may have a slight deficiency in speed, power, or defensive range that prevents them from reaching S-tier status.

1. Rafael Devers – 3B, Red Sox
Rafael Devers offers tremendous power, particularly to the pull side, making him a constant home run threat. While his contact rating isn’t as elite against off-speed pitches, Devers’ slugging potential compensates in late-inning situations. Defensively, he is competent but slightly slower than other S-tier third basemen, making positioning critical.

2. Bo Bichette – SS, Blue Jays
Bo Bichette shines with a blend of contact and speed that allows for aggressive baserunning and consistent offensive output. His defense is solid, though his arm can occasionally be a liability on long throws. Bichette excels in modes where speed and versatility are prioritized over pure power, making him a strategic choice for balanced squads.

3. Matt Chapman – 3B, Athletics
Chapman’s glove is his standout feature. With one of the highest reaction and fielding ratings in the game, he can make highlight-reel plays daily. Offensively, his power is respectable, but his contact ratings against breaking balls can make him less reliable in tight situations. Chapman is a defensive anchor, perfect for teams that emphasize infield stability.

Tier B: Solid Performers with Specific Roles

Tier B infielders are dependable but generally serve more specialized roles. They may excel in defense, base stealing, or situational hitting rather than being a full-package superstar.

1. Brandon Lowe – 2B, Rays
Brandon Lowe is an excellent gap hitter with decent power, but his defensive range is average. He thrives in lineups that prioritize offensive output at second base while allowing other teammates to cover the defensive spectrum.

2. Javier Báez – SS, Tigers
Báez is a flashy player who can make incredible defensive plays and turn double plays with style. His offense can be streaky, and low patience ratings at the plate sometimes lead to strikeouts. However, in high-risk, high-reward scenarios, he is a must-have for his defensive versatility.

3. Paul Goldschmidt – 1B, Cardinals
Goldschmidt provides steady offense with good contact and power ratings, but his speed is minimal, limiting baserunning potential. He is a reliable choice for teams looking for a consistent right-handed bat at first base with dependable fielding.

Tier C: Role Players and Specialists

Tier C infielders are best used in specific situations or as backups. They may have glaring weaknesses in either offensive production or defensive ability.

1. Ke’Bryan Hayes – 3B, Pirates
Hayes is defensively capable but lacks the offensive firepower to compete with Tier A or S-tier third basemen consistently. He works best as a late-inning defensive replacement or against favorable pitching matchups.

2. José Altuve – 2B, Astros
Altuve remains a veteran presence, with good contact and speed ratings. However, his power has declined, and reaction times are slightly lower than peak years, making him a situational option rather than a primary offensive driver.

3. Miguel Cabrera – 1B, Retired/Legend Cards
In MLB The Show 25, Cabrera is available as a legend or flashback card. While he has historical significance and solid offensive stats, lower speed and defensive ratings limit his practical utility in competitive modes.

Conclusion

September’s infield tier list for MLB The Show 25 highlights the elite talent that can make a dramatic difference in Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, and Road to the Show gameplay. S-tier players like José Ramírez, Freddie Freeman, and Trea Turner offer unmatched versatility and dominance, while Tier A and B players provide specialized roles to strengthen team depth. Tier C serves as situational or backup options, useful for roster flexibility but not the core of a powerhouse squad.

When constructing your team this month, consider not only raw stats but also synergy with your lineup, defensive strategy, and baserunning philosophy. By combining S-tier stars with strong supporting players, you can maximize performance and dominate the diamond in MLB The Show 25.

Whether you’re grinding for a perfect Road to cheap MLB The Show S 25 Stubs the Show season or aiming to climb the ranks in Diamond Dynasty, understanding which infielders shine right now is key. September’s list proves that the right combination of speed, power, defense, and versatility can turn any team into a contender.